CBRL
- Market cap
- $1.42B
- Sector
- Consumer discretionary
Discounted cash flow · Against the price, $63.80 on 9 Sep 2026 · Traffic falls and costs rise faster than menu prices
Discounted cash flow · Against the price, $63.80 on 9 Sep 2026 · Traffic steadies and the margin returns towards four per cent
Discounted cash flow · Against the price, $63.80 on 9 Sep 2026 · Dining room and shop both grow and the margin passes five per cent
Cracker Barrel's price is $63.80, below the base case's $67.39, with the bear case at $53.17 and the bull case at $80.80. The discounted cash flow reads close to the price and the company's own multiples read above it; the dividend model reads far under it, and none of them can see whether guests keep coming back.
The next report that tests the cases is the next quarterly one, and the line to read in it is traffic against price.
Thesis as of 8 Sep 2026; score updated 9 Sep 2026.
Traffic falls and costs rise faster than menu prices Guests visit less often and wage and food costs rise faster than the menu does, so operating margin slips below two and a half per cent.
A condition the bear case rests on Same-store restaurant sales below zero for two quarters.
A condition the base case needs Operating margin above 3% on the trailing twelve months.
The next quarterly report Traffic against price.
The report after it Food and hourly labour costs against menu prices: the margin has little room before the dividend takes most of a smaller profit.
| Case | Bear case | Base case | Bull case | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value | $53.17−16.7% | $67.39+5.6% | $80.80+26.6% | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Value by model |
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Headline | Traffic falls and costs rise faster than menu prices | Traffic steadies and the margin returns towards four per cent | Dining room and shop both grow and the margin passes five per cent | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Argument | Guests visit less often and wage and food costs rise faster than the menu does, so operating margin slips below two and a half per cent. The dividend then takes a larger share of a smaller profit. | Traffic steadies, menu prices rise with costs and the shop keeps near a fifth of revenue. Operating margin returns towards four per cent. | Traffic grows and the shop's mix improves, so operating margin passes five per cent and cash left after the dividend rises. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Key years |
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Settings | Revenue growth at 0.50× the base path, margins at 0.92×, long-run growth 1.50%, exit multiple at the low end of its band. | The base case's own path: growth, margins and long-run growth as the run published them. | Revenue growth at 1.40× the base path, margins at 1.05×, long-run growth 2.50%, exit multiple at the high end of its band. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Conditions |
|
|
|
| Model | Value | Against the price | The thesis on it | Open |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Discounted cash flow | $67.39 | +5.6% | A cross-check on the cases: the street's revenue path, discounted at the company's own cost of capital. | BearBaseBullOpen |
| Exit multiples | $60.75 | −4.8% | Forward earnings or cash flow sold at the multiples this company has traded on, discounted once. | BearBaseBullOpen |
| Relative valuation | $72.89 | +14.3% | Today's ratios at their own five-year averages: it keeps whatever the multiple has meant in the past. | Open |
| Analyst targets | $76.56 | +20.0% | 20 analysts from $60.64 to $107.81. The street's targets are third parties' words, listed beside the models and never averaged into them. | Open |
| Dividend discount | $31.71 | −50.3% | The dividend model, run on the payout the company has kept. | Open |
| Peer comparison | not shown | — | Peer comparison is stored and shown on the Peers tab as measures, not as a value. | Open |
Each driver: rationale, current reading, bull and bear triggers.
| Driver | Why it matters | Reading now | Toward the bull case | Toward the bear case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upside driverTraffic steadies and the margin returns towards four per centNext release · At the next quarterly report | Traffic steadies, menu prices rise with costs and the shop keeps near a fifth of revenue. | The base case's first condition: operating margin above 3% on the trailing twelve months. | same-store restaurant sales above 3%. | same-store restaurant sales below zero for two quarters. |
| Upside driverDining room and shop both grow and the margin passes five per centNext release · At the next quarterly report | Traffic grows and the shop's mix improves, so operating margin passes five per cent and cash left after the dividend rises. | The bull case's first condition: same-store restaurant sales above 3%. | same-store restaurant sales above 3%. | same-store restaurant sales below zero for two quarters. |
| Downside driverTraffic falls and costs rise faster than menu pricesNext release · At the next quarterly report | Guests visit less often and wage and food costs rise faster than the menu does, so operating margin slips below two and a half per cent. | The bear case's first condition: same-store restaurant sales below zero for two quarters. | same-store restaurant sales above 3%. | same-store restaurant sales below zero for two quarters. |
Illustrative: written by hand for this preview from the evidence of 8 Sep 2026, not by a model. A reading of the evidence, not a recommendation.