Back to blog

Smart money

How to read an insider filing, and why the lag matters

Company insiders must report their trades on a Form 4. Reading one takes a minute once you know the few fields that carry the story.

When an officer, a director or a large shareholder of a US-listed company buys or sells its shares, they report it to the SEC on a Form 4. The filing is public, and it is one of the clearest records of what people closest to a company do with their own money.

The rule exists so that the people who know a company best cannot trade quietly on what they know. It does not forbid insiders from trading; it makes the trades visible. What a reader does with that visibility is the interesting part, and it starts with reading the form properly.

The fields worth reading

  • Who filed, and in what role: chief executive, finance chief, director, or a holder of more than ten percent of the shares.
  • The transaction date: the day the trade happened, which is not the day it was reported.
  • The transaction code: a letter that says what kind of trade it was.
  • The number of shares and the price per share.
  • The shares owned afterwards: how large the trade is compared with the holding.
  • Whether the trade was made under a pre-arranged plan.
The transaction codes you will meet most often
CodeMeaning
PPurchase on the open market
SSale on the open market
AA grant or award from the company
MExercise of an option or similar right
FShares withheld to pay tax

Plan or discretionary

Many insiders sell under a written plan, set up in advance, that fixes the dates or prices of future sales. A plan sale tells you little about the insider's view that week, because the decision was taken earlier. A discretionary trade, made on the day with no plan, is a choice made with current knowledge. Oryn labels the difference on every row, since reading one as the other is the commonest mistake.

Purchases and sales also differ in how much they can mean. People sell for many reasons that have nothing to do with a company: a house, a tax bill, diversifying a large holding. People buy with their own money for fewer.

The lag

A Form 4 is due within two business days of the trade. So by the time you read one, the trade is already a few days old, and the price may have moved. That gap is the filing lag, and it is the most important number on the page after the trade itself.

Oryn prints the lag beside every trade, for example "Disclosed after 4 days", and marks an unusually late one with a word. It never hides it. The same applies elsewhere: a fund's quarterly 13F holdings report arrives within 45 days of the quarter's end, and a member of Congress's trades under the STOCK Act can be disclosed weeks later. Each has its own lag, and each is shown.

Putting it together

A cluster of discretionary purchases by several insiders in a short window says more than one trade by one person. A single plan sale says very little. And whatever you read, the filing describes the past: it is evidence about what people did, not a forecast of what a price will do.

That is why Oryn treats these filings as one input among several, under the smart-money part of the score, and not as a signal on their own.

Research and education, not investment advice. Nothing in this post is a recommendation or an offer to buy or sell any security, and it takes no account of any reader's objectives, financial situation or needs. Worked numbers are invented to show arithmetic. This is a sample post for the preview.

Back to blog